- The facts that decide delay claims are the facts that run a project: programmes, diaries, instructions and notices.
- Most of the cost of a delay claim goes on finding and rebuilding records after the event.
- Late notices can extinguish good claims, and many amended contracts shorten the notice period.
- Keeping the record properly as the job runs costs little and often settles disagreements early.
Where claims are actually lost
After many years of preparing and reviewing delay analyses, one lesson repeats. Strong claims are rarely lost on the law or on the method. They are lost on the record. The event happened, the delay was real, but the evidence was not kept in a form that proves it.
The cost shows up in two places. First, entitlement is lost outright when a notice was late or never sent. Second, a large part of the expert's fee goes on finding, cleaning and reconstructing records that should have existed in usable form from the start.
The five records that matter
Across FIDIC, NEC, GCC and JBCC contracts, the same records decide most delay disputes:
- The accepted baseline programme and every update, kept exactly as issued.
- Daily site diaries, with resources, weather and the work actually achieved.
- Instructions and variations, with the activities each one affected.
- Early warnings and notices, with the clause cited and proof of delivery.
- Minutes and correspondence that show what each party knew and when.
These are also the records a well run project needs to control time and cost. The evidence for arbitration and the information for management are the same information, recorded one time.
Notices and time bars
Many standard forms make entitlement to time or money conditional on notice within a set period. Under FIDIC 2017 the contractor's notice of claim is due within 28 days of becoming aware of the event. Amended contracts often shorten that period. A notice on day 29 can extinguish an otherwise good claim.
The practical fix is simple. Raise the warning or notice at the point the problem is recorded, from the diary or the progress return, with the contract's clause and named recipients already known to the system. CIP's Progress and Commercial module works this way, so the notice and its timing become part of the project record.
Programmes kept as issued
The SCL Delay and Disruption Protocol encourages parties to agree and maintain an accepted programme and to update it regularly with progress. When updates are overwritten, or kept only as the latest file, an expert later has to rebuild them. Every rebuilt update invites argument about its assumptions.
Keeping each update as issued, alongside the baseline, avoids that argument. It also lets the project team see drift early, while there is still time to recover it.
What dispute ready means in practice
Dispute ready does not mean preparing for a fight. It means the project record is complete, dated and linked, so that if a dispute does arise, the facts are already organised. In our experience, a clear record often settles a disagreement before it becomes a formal dispute, because both sides can see what happened.
A checklist for your next project
- Agree the baseline early and store it as accepted, with its Basis of Schedule.
- Issue updates on a fixed cycle and keep every one as issued.
- Record the diary every day, by activity, with resources from a fixed list.
- Diarise every notice period from the contract, including amendments.
- Send notices from a controlled system that records who received them and when.
- Link instructions and events to the activities they affect.
Questions people ask
- What does dispute ready mean?
- It means the project record is complete, dated and linked as the work happens, so that if a dispute arises the facts are already organised and do not need to be reconstructed.
- Does preparing for disputes make them more likely?
- In our experience the opposite is true. When both parties can see a clear record of what happened, disagreements are more often resolved before they become formal disputes.
- Which delay analysis method should we use?
- The right method depends on the contract, the records available and the question being asked. The SCL Delay and Disruption Protocol describes the main methods. Good contemporaneous records widen the choice and strengthen whichever method is used.